Against Therapy

A trained psychoanalyst turns against his own profession and argues, with devastating historical evidence, that the very structure of therapy harms the people it claims to help. This is the book the mental health industry has been trying to bury since 1988. From the author of the bestseller The Assault on Truth.

From the bestselling author of The Assault on Truth

The person you're paying to help you may be the one doing the harm.

You've sat in the chair. You've told a stranger your worst memories. And somewhere in the back of your mind, a question formed that you weren't supposed to ask: Is this actually helping, or is something else going on here?

Jeffrey Moussaieff Masson, a trained psychoanalyst who spent eight years inside the profession before walking away from it, argues that the problem with therapy isn't just bad practitioners. It's the structure itself. In Against Therapy, he traces the profession from its nineteenth-century roots, where women were institutionalized for wanting independence, through Freud's decision to recast his patients' real memories of sexual abuse as fantasy, to modern cases of therapists who physically and sexually abused patients while colleagues looked the other way. He draws on private diaries, asylum archives, and clinical case histories that the profession has spent decades trying to keep quiet.

What emerges is a pattern that cuts across every school of thought:

• 
  The therapist decides what's "real" and what's projection. Disagree, and you're showing "resistance."
  
• 
  Concepts like transference and acting out function less as science and more as tools to keep the patient subordinate.
  
• 
  Research consistently shows that untrained college professors achieve outcomes comparable to experienced therapists.
  

Masson isn't anti-patient. He's clear that people seek therapy for legitimate reasons, real pain, real trauma. His argument is that the profession exploits that pain by claiming an expertise it cannot deliver, inside a relationship where the power only flows one direction.

This is the book the therapy industry doesn't want you to read. If you've ever wondered whether the couch is really where the answers are, start here.